Showing posts with label computers. Show all posts
Showing posts with label computers. Show all posts

Friday, August 10, 2012

Cloudy With a Chance of False Security

It's been barely more than a decade since the internet slipped into our homes in earnest, and even though we're still getting used to it the technology has been moving like a loaded shopping cart going down a hill--there's no telling what direction it's going to go in and it's not going to stop unless it hits something big, in which case there's going to be a major mess.

If you haven't yet heard about Mat Honan's experience of having been epically hacked over on Wired, I suggeest you check it out immediately. It seriously underscores the nature of the online world we're living in today, a world that's snuck up on a lot of us. In short, in the course of an attack by hackers who wanted to seize control of his Twitter account for the lulz, Honan ended up having his digital life deleted. It's the online equivalent of having everything you own wiped out in a house fire, and it's not something I'd wish on anyone.

Nevertheless, when I encountered this news it underscored to me the problems of the ongoing rush to the cloud, to having our own personal information stored on a hard drive in some unknown server farm that might be in a cave on Spitsbergen for all the difference that it makes. Honan shouldn't have been able to have been hacked--his attackers were able to get access to his digital life by exploiting security flaws in Apple and Amazon accounts, but I don't just mean that holes like that should have been patched before anyone had an opportunity to punch a fist through one.

No, I'm more of the opinion that there shouldn't be a case where this sort of damage can be done entirely remotely and online.

Clouds ahead, and we keep flying on.

The idea of the cloud isn't a new one. Following on the heels of tech forecasters, Scott Adams of Dilbert recognized its shadow coming back in 1998, when in The Dilbert Future he predicted the coming challenge of the Network Computer, "a PC with no hard drive (or a tiny one)... [that] downloads software from the Internet and executes it on an as-needed basis." Even then, I thought it was a cheapjack notion; why else would anyone want to surrender control over their own software, their own productivity, their own information? Taking advantage of the cloud for certain specific, occasional tasks is one thing, like renting a car to take a vacation for the weekend when you don't own one yourself. While the state of the internet has improved since 1998--after all, the cloud wasn't feasible technically when everyone was still using dialup, and could get kicked off whenever someone upstairs needed to use the phone--I don't think it's addressed the underlying problems. To me, making use of the cloud for basic, day-to-day stuff feels like living out of a storage locker.

Because it isn't really secure--Honan's story demonstrates that, and just because it's one of the first that doesn't mean it will be the last. Apple has supposedly taken action to patch the security hole that Honan's attackers targeted, but there will always be vulnerabilities waiting to be exploited. The cloud can be easy and user-friendly, but that sort of thing comes at the expense of security. When it comes to my digital life, my important files and photos and so on, I keep them backed up on an external hard drive that is only ever connected to a computer when the backup process is underway. Aside from that, it's an isolated system that can't be reached by any online attack.

I've never trusted the cloud. Purely electronic things on my hard drive are ephemeral enough--the cloud takes this just one step beyond, so that the ephemeral things I use aren't even in something I can control. In the end, the key to security is control.

Tuesday, September 6, 2011

The Pad's Way

So, because of my own foolishness I'm forced to be making this update on an iPad - though due to Safari incomprehensibly lacking the key HTML support necessary for writing in the text box, I'm writing this text in an email - and it's a strange experience. This is the first time I've used an iPad for any length of time, and it's idiosyncrasies are significantly different from the more beefy computers I've been familiar with over the past fifteen years. Such as, for example, Autocorrect, as you can see by that "it's" up there.

Not that it's EASY to write on an iPad. That "EASY" took eight keystrokes, for example.

Which is really the crux of it, though I don't know if it extends to other tablet computers. The iPad is good for watching, for reading, for perusing - but not creating. Writing with a digital keyboard that obligates me to regress back to hunt-and-peck is a chore. From what I've seen the basic word-processing capabilities are purely nominal. I can watch YouTube videos, but neither comment on them nor see the existing comments thanks to Steve Jobs' animus against Flash, and while plenty of YouTube comments are better left unseen, removing the option entirely reduces it to essentially online television.

Put simply, the iPad seems to be a device geared for consumption, not creation, and while the concept did arise organically as a natural midpoint between computers and smartphones, I suspect that in years to come tablets such as this will be pushed ever more strongly on the population. Transhumance Space forecast a world where general-purpose computers were made illegal by 2015, and while I don't expect to see that come true I do expect to see governments and corporations alike encourage a paradigm shift in computing that just happens to make people less participatory and more pliant. Don't maintain a blog, just read the online newspapers. Don't comment online, let other people make your opinion heard. Don't think, just agree and consume.

I think it may be closer than we think.

Sunday, February 20, 2011

Ask, and Understand

I didn't watch the recent man vs. machine series on Jeopardy! this past week, so all the information I'm getting about how IBM's Watson crushed its human competitors has been filtered through other sources - but that's okay. The most fundamental thing that we should take from this is that clear-language interaction with computers - something that's been a staple of science fiction for decades - has taken a huge step toward reality, despite speedbumps such as answering "Toronto" in a Final Jeopardy category about United States cities. Watson wasn't fooled by the wordplay and the back-and-forth; it was able to to pierce through the doubletalk and understand what was being asked of it.

That bears repeating: a computer program that understands something. There are plenty of people who think that this is just a dim shadow of what's waiting for us in the very near future. As potentially world-shaking as the Singularity could be, supposing that we ever agree on how to define the damn thing and then it actually happens, that's not one of the implications of Watson's victory that I've been thinking about much.

Specifically, the social implications of people having access to individual question-answerer programs. What if, in ten years, every smartphone literally is a smart phone, and comes equipped with a descendant of Watson that can answer any question you ask of it so long as it has sufficient time to poke around for answers on the internet? Considering the pace of development over the last ten years, I would not be surprised for the phones of 2021 to function as oracles as well.

But what does this do to people? Consider the modern day - how often do you encounter stories of people driving themselves into ditches, or into farmers' fields, or into an illegal turn across multiple lanes of traffic because their GPS told them to, and they obeyed it without question? Let's be honest... critical thinking isn't exactly part of the school curriculum in North America at least, and there are plenty of people out there who don't know how to think think. People have always wanted easy answers. What's going to happen when it's as easy as asking your phone when you've got a burning question, and uncritically accepting whatever it flings back at you as the truth?

One thing I'll always remember about school is that research is difficult. It's hard to find good and appropriate sources, to sort through those sources, to figure out what material you need and to identify biases in the text and distill it down so you can answer the question in front of you. For me, the research phase of an essay took weeks - and that was even without waiting for worthwhile sources to get there through interlibrary loan. Consider how many people would leap at the opportunity to skip all that effort - hell, it's practically what we see now, with some students shamelessly cribbing from Wikipedia articles, or going whole hog and buying essays from mills. Who cares about understanding the answer, so long as you have it?

Understanding is the key. An answered question is worthless unless you know what the answer means. As our computers become more and more sophisticated and capable of interacting with us on more meaningful levels, we need to take care that we avoid falling into the trap of complacency - of working toward a world where our computers understand its workings better than we do.

Sunday, August 22, 2010

Enhancing Character Awareness

One of the biggest problems a writer will face is convincing the characters to do what the writer knows is necessary. The fact is, characters aren't robots - whether or not they're empowered with a will of their own on the page, the fact remains is that their words and actions establish their perspectives, motives, and desires, and forcing characters to arrive at decisions through pure authorial fiat cheapens a work immensely. Good writers can manipulate the characters, make them believe that they're doing things for their own reason, seeing things with their own eyes.

Still, sometimes the temptation to use authorial intervention to solve an intractable or just difficult problem is too much. I notice it frequently in works of fantasy, where it almost seems to be a staple of the genre - prophetic visions or clairvoyant revelations that give the characters insight into the future, and also serve as easily-installed motives. Say that you've got this sorcerer in a far-off land who you plan to be the Big Bad of the series, but your characters have no reason to even be aware of him, let alone willing to challenge him. Sure, you could weave a complex plot together where the protagonist and the antagonist gradually come into each other's lives through ordinary circumstances and invent their own reasons to stand in opposition - or, you could just have some convenient soothsayer grant a character a vision of what this sorcerer will do when he achieves the power he seeks, and motivate the protagonist to prevent that vision from ever coming to pass.

Personally, I feel that pulling that particular trick out of the writer's toolbox cheapens the work. I believe that a protagonist should travel through the narrative and emerge victorious on their own merits, rather than because of some ineffable gift of second sight.

It's when this same line of thinking shows up in science fiction and other, more reality-rooted genres that I really start to get irritated. Fantasy gets a pass for a lot of things specifically because it is fantasy; the whole genre is practically a paean of longing for things we can't have because the universe is a meanie. To be perfectly blunt, I expect better from things that claim to be science fiction. I speak, specifically, of the Enhance Button.

Zoom in on A4 and rotate the bitmap around the Z axis all you want - the only thing that matters is that pixels gotta come from somewhere.

It's a staple both in modern science fiction and police procedural/mystery shows for the magical computer to take a small, grainy, poorly-resolved image and transform it into something of perfect sharpness - generally it's a key clue or deciding piece of evidence for the main characters, and without it they would be flailing about like a fish on the dock.

This is nothing more than an expression of the same motives that lie behind fantasy's prophetic visions - and, hell, science fiction frequently incorporates prophecy like it's no big thing. Look at Minority Report - without precognition, the story would fall completely apart. More recently, you can find it in StarCraft II's reeling, staggering narrative with the Ihan crystal missions.

What crystallized this for me was a two-part episode of the mystery series Castle, which I can watch thanks to CTV streaming it on their website. In the second-season episode "Boom!," the NYPD is on the trail of a crazy killer who has sent a video of himself with a captive to taunt them. Fortunately, the characters have a magical computer at their disposal. Not only are they able to zoom-enhance a light-drowned corner of a window into a recognizeable image of a New York City bridge, they're also able to completely strip out parts of the audio track with a few keystrokes, thereby isolating the sound of a passing elevated subway train. They then use the sound and the angle of the bridge view to establish precisely where the killer was holed up - and all this in barely more than sixty seconds.

What makes this even more hilarious is that, from the way the rest of the episode unfolds, the killer had expected the police to discover exactly this.

I know from experience that one of the hardest parts of writing is making a worthwhile villain, because they don't have the decency to make some elementary, stupid mistake that the protagonist sees through in an instant. But to create a villain that does cover his bases and have the protagonist make her way to him because of revelations from a magical computer or a prophetic vision doesn't do a work justice.

Sunday, August 8, 2010

A Robot Must Obey

Yesterday I lost a multiplayer match of StarCraft II because my computer turned itself off to install automatic updates. To be honest, it ultimately was my fault - it had been needling me to do so for days, but I'd kept on just clicking "postpone." The installation of automatic updates requires that the computer be rebooted a few times, and I dislike rebooting unnecessarily. The problem is that when it happened, it came completely by surprise. The computer restarted after a fifteen-minute countdown, but a countdown that popped under. Since I was busy trying desperately to find a tactic that would end with my opponent not standing atop the broken remnants of my base, my first indication of its presence was when programs started shutting down of their own accord.

Without giving me a chance to save, either.

Over the last few decades our civilization has been computerized to a great degree, and this is a trend that's only going to gain strength in the coming years. We're at the point now where armed military robots are no longer science fiction, but are being used in theatres of operation at this moment. If that's going to continue to be the case, we can't just let our current operating procedures stand. My issue was minor - it meant my opponent could find someone else to smash sooner, and I lost a few points on the division ladder - but it arose from the computer's programming telling it to embark on an action unless that action was specifically countermanded.

The attention of a human in a serious issue is important, but humans can only divide their attention so much - and sometimes, be it through information overload or programming defect, the computer's message to the operator may be missed. If we're not careful, this could lead to a future where automated systems put dangerous wheels in motion because no human contradicted them in time. Things are stressful enough without a ticking clock, especially one that has no reason to be there.

This is the sort of thing that creeps in, a bit at a time. No one's ever going to sit down and say "you know what? Let's make it so that computers figure out what we're going to do." No, they'll automate control of low-priority systems, always intending to keep humans in the loop, but as things go on and as the organization paying the bills realizes that automated decision loops mean that they can get by with fewer humans on the payroll, people may gradually but steadily get crowded out. It happens by degrees - the sort of transition that humans are the worst at perceiving until it's too late, or nearly so, to do anything about. I've heard stories of automated stock trading that's caused a company's share price to crash utterly because of the decisions some computer program made - I can't recall now if it actually happened or is just an urban legend, but the danger is there just the same. It would certainly make it harder to make those systems Three Laws-compliant.

Freedom of choice is one of the most valuable things in the universe. If we invest the course-choosing mechanisms of our civilization in machines that will act unless specifically instructed otherwise, well - at that point, whose civilization is it _really_?